Fantastic Four #10
Wait, what? That cover to the left says #4. So why did I link it with #10? Because apparently the same variant cover was used for both issues. Yeah.
Anyway:
Yancy Street.
Yancy Street.
Yancy Street.
Yancy Street.
Yancy Street.
Yancy Street.
Get the picture yet? This is quite possibly the most obnoxious single issue of a comic book I have ever read. Lots of Tom King Batman readers thought "I'll break his damn back" was too repetitive. But at least King had a reason. Dan Slott references Yancy Street so many times in this issue, I know it was deliberate. Maybe not deliberately awful. But it might as well have been.
The idea, for this "War of the Realms" tie-in, is that, in typical Marvel fashion, characters are really proud to be New Yorkers, and in this instance, to be residents of a particular neighborhood, a famous one in Fantastic Four lore, but...
You don't need to repeat "Yancy Street" so often to make this point. It. Becomes. Irredeemably. Obnoxious.
It's the exact opposite of what Slott really needed to do to make his point. In fact, he ruined his point, with this approach. He wanted his characters to be proud to be New Yorkers, to defend their own neighborhood, to prove to a bunch of bullies that if they really wanted to make something of themselves, they would embrace the community.
So Slott uses a sledgehammer to wham every single letter of "Yancy Street" into the reader's head. Every single reader. Individually.
By the end of the issue, I desperately wanted some urban development done. Make it a parking lot. Anything but whatever Slott thought he was accomplishing.
Yancy Street. Yesh.
Showing posts with label Dan Slott. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dan Slott. Show all posts
Sunday, February 9, 2020
Sunday, August 5, 2018
Reading Comics 220 "Spotlight Nation...and a sort of Batwedding"
Picked up one of Marvel's Free Spotlight comics with Dan Slott's Fantastic Four on the cover, with four pages from this month's relaunch. There's been a lot of talk that Marvel took the FF off the board as a bargaining chip (seems to have worked) to get the movie rights back, dating back to Jonathan Hickman's Secret Wars, where Reed Richards and Doctor Doom had their most epic showdown to date. Since then Johnny Storm and Ben Grimm have appeared in various team books. And of course it's Johnny and Ben who appear in these preview pages.
There's also Gerry Duggan offering a look at Infinity Wars, which apparently will feature an Infinity Watch of heroes and villains protecting the various Infinity Gems. Clearly calculated as an event to follow on the heels of Avengers: Infinity War at the movies. Then there's Extermination, another X-Men event; a page detailing various Miracleman collections, including a Neil Gaiman volume called The Golden Age perhaps in the hope more material will eventually follow; various other one-and-two-page ads, including for Charles Soule's Return of Wolverine featuring the infamous new flaming claws; four pages of Cullen Bunn's Asgardians of the Galaxy, which is another cue from the movies, borrowing elements from Thor: Ragnarok; and finally four from Kelly Thompson's West Coast Avengers, which features both Hawkeyes and land sharks that do not try and pretend to be delivering things.
DC Nation #0 (DC)
Besides looks at Brian Michael Bendis's Superman and Scott Snyder's Justice League, this quarter-priced special released just before Free Comic Book Day this year featured a wicked Joker story from Tom King in anticipation of the Batwedding, in which the Clown Prince breaks into someone's home and he waits there, along with the poor guy, for an invitation. It's as perfect a representation of Joker's twisted logic and sense of humor as I've ever seen. A lot of fans swear by Alan Moore's Killing Joke, but I think that one speaks more to Moore's proclivities than it does Joker's. King's Joker had a great spotlight in "War of Jokes and Riddles," in which he tries to figure out why nothing seems funny to him anymore, before realizing that Batman gives him bold new context, a challenge that will never get old. Here he's just free to terrorize the poor guy, using his singular logic.
Batman #50 (DC)
The main event, though, the issue that promised the actual Batwedding, angered a lot of fans because the wedding...doesn't happen. Instead, it proves an elaborate setup to the events of "I Am Bane," the earlier arc where Batman prevented Bane from attaining his Psycho-Pirate happy ending. Holly Robinson, who has proven so crucial to King's Catwoman, turns out to be a stooge of Bane, and whispers in Catwoman's ear doubt about what a happy ending would do to Batman. So the issue is instead really another caption character study of Batman and Catwoman's perspectives. No one has done that sort of thing as well as King since Jeph Loeb's early Superman/Batman.
Eternity #2, 4 (Valiant)
I went back and read #3, which I'd caught earlier, too, and that turned out to be a good idea, because it reads better in context, obviously, and is just a pleasure to read again in general. Eternity is the fourth volume of Matt Kindt's brilliant Divinity suite, in which Kindt reimagines the idea of the omnipotent hero previously featured in Moore's Watchmen under the guise of Dr. Manhattan, this time as a Russian cosmonaut and his colleagues, one of whom became his wife and the other a foe, while he inspired a fanatic who has proven far more troublesome than he could've possibly imagined. Eternity was pitched as beyond imagination, so its ending is apropos, the true consequences of Abram Adams's transformation far more wild than anything he discovers from the world that changed him forever. Hopefully there's a fifth volume of this stuff. The ending of this one certainly suggests that the story continues, anyway...
The Flash #50 (DC)
Josh Williamson continues his Rebirth buildup of previous lore by concluding the "Flash War" fight between Barry Allen and Wally West amicably and bringing back the classic Bart Allen in his classic Impulse costume. Howard Porter's career renaissance continues, and that's great to see from a reader who well-remembers his JLA heyday.
There's also Gerry Duggan offering a look at Infinity Wars, which apparently will feature an Infinity Watch of heroes and villains protecting the various Infinity Gems. Clearly calculated as an event to follow on the heels of Avengers: Infinity War at the movies. Then there's Extermination, another X-Men event; a page detailing various Miracleman collections, including a Neil Gaiman volume called The Golden Age perhaps in the hope more material will eventually follow; various other one-and-two-page ads, including for Charles Soule's Return of Wolverine featuring the infamous new flaming claws; four pages of Cullen Bunn's Asgardians of the Galaxy, which is another cue from the movies, borrowing elements from Thor: Ragnarok; and finally four from Kelly Thompson's West Coast Avengers, which features both Hawkeyes and land sharks that do not try and pretend to be delivering things.
DC Nation #0 (DC)
Besides looks at Brian Michael Bendis's Superman and Scott Snyder's Justice League, this quarter-priced special released just before Free Comic Book Day this year featured a wicked Joker story from Tom King in anticipation of the Batwedding, in which the Clown Prince breaks into someone's home and he waits there, along with the poor guy, for an invitation. It's as perfect a representation of Joker's twisted logic and sense of humor as I've ever seen. A lot of fans swear by Alan Moore's Killing Joke, but I think that one speaks more to Moore's proclivities than it does Joker's. King's Joker had a great spotlight in "War of Jokes and Riddles," in which he tries to figure out why nothing seems funny to him anymore, before realizing that Batman gives him bold new context, a challenge that will never get old. Here he's just free to terrorize the poor guy, using his singular logic.
Batman #50 (DC)
The main event, though, the issue that promised the actual Batwedding, angered a lot of fans because the wedding...doesn't happen. Instead, it proves an elaborate setup to the events of "I Am Bane," the earlier arc where Batman prevented Bane from attaining his Psycho-Pirate happy ending. Holly Robinson, who has proven so crucial to King's Catwoman, turns out to be a stooge of Bane, and whispers in Catwoman's ear doubt about what a happy ending would do to Batman. So the issue is instead really another caption character study of Batman and Catwoman's perspectives. No one has done that sort of thing as well as King since Jeph Loeb's early Superman/Batman.
Eternity #2, 4 (Valiant)
I went back and read #3, which I'd caught earlier, too, and that turned out to be a good idea, because it reads better in context, obviously, and is just a pleasure to read again in general. Eternity is the fourth volume of Matt Kindt's brilliant Divinity suite, in which Kindt reimagines the idea of the omnipotent hero previously featured in Moore's Watchmen under the guise of Dr. Manhattan, this time as a Russian cosmonaut and his colleagues, one of whom became his wife and the other a foe, while he inspired a fanatic who has proven far more troublesome than he could've possibly imagined. Eternity was pitched as beyond imagination, so its ending is apropos, the true consequences of Abram Adams's transformation far more wild than anything he discovers from the world that changed him forever. Hopefully there's a fifth volume of this stuff. The ending of this one certainly suggests that the story continues, anyway...
The Flash #50 (DC)
Josh Williamson continues his Rebirth buildup of previous lore by concluding the "Flash War" fight between Barry Allen and Wally West amicably and bringing back the classic Bart Allen in his classic Impulse costume. Howard Porter's career renaissance continues, and that's great to see from a reader who well-remembers his JLA heyday.
Thursday, March 30, 2017
Reading Comics 202 "Third LCS Visit 2017"
American Gods #1 (Dark Horse)
An adaptation of Neil Gaiman's novel, which is soon to be debuted in another adaptation, for television. I haven't read the book in years, but I liked it quite a lot. Still, reading some of it in comics form makes me realize it really has been years, so I may have to reread it.
Batman #19 (DC)
Tom King sets up an epic clash between Bane and Batman. He continues to write sensationally.
Divinity III: Stalinverse #3 (Valiant)
Matt Kindt likewise continues to write sensationally.
The Amazing Spider-Man #25 (Marvel)
Dan Slott's epic run continues, this time with Norman Osborn. I actually picked this up because Stuart Immonen begins his run (he's done Peter Parker before in the pages of Ultimate Spider-Man) with the issue. Thankfully he retains his return to streamlined work previously seen in Empress and other recent work. Actually, the most notable thing about the issue is Slott introducing...the Superior Octopus. Which is really, really awesome.
Star Trek: Waypoint #4 (IDW)
The first Enterprise-focused comic ever! Phlox was featured in a doctors confab a few years ago, but this is the first time the fifth live action series has gotten its own comics adaptation. The writer somewhat flubs the opportunity, but still rightfully puts Porthos in the spotlight. It's always about Porthos!
Superman #19 (DC)
Action Comics #976 (DC)
Peter Tomasi and Patrick Gleason are their usual sensational selves in the first issue, while Dan Jurgens continues to struggle to adapt to modern storytelling in the second. But I like the "Reborn" concept and how Mxyzptlk was revealed to be behind the Clark Kent mystery, and how Jurgens gets to unique disparate continuities in the conclusion, which feels right regardless of my other qualms.
X-O Manowar #1 (Valiant)
Matt Kindt again, in this quasi-reboot of the franchise, completely nailing it. Might be viewed as the Dark Knight Returns/"Old Man Logan" for comics' most famous Visigoth.
An adaptation of Neil Gaiman's novel, which is soon to be debuted in another adaptation, for television. I haven't read the book in years, but I liked it quite a lot. Still, reading some of it in comics form makes me realize it really has been years, so I may have to reread it.
Batman #19 (DC)
Tom King sets up an epic clash between Bane and Batman. He continues to write sensationally.
Divinity III: Stalinverse #3 (Valiant)
Matt Kindt likewise continues to write sensationally.
The Amazing Spider-Man #25 (Marvel)
Dan Slott's epic run continues, this time with Norman Osborn. I actually picked this up because Stuart Immonen begins his run (he's done Peter Parker before in the pages of Ultimate Spider-Man) with the issue. Thankfully he retains his return to streamlined work previously seen in Empress and other recent work. Actually, the most notable thing about the issue is Slott introducing...the Superior Octopus. Which is really, really awesome.
Star Trek: Waypoint #4 (IDW)
The first Enterprise-focused comic ever! Phlox was featured in a doctors confab a few years ago, but this is the first time the fifth live action series has gotten its own comics adaptation. The writer somewhat flubs the opportunity, but still rightfully puts Porthos in the spotlight. It's always about Porthos!
Superman #19 (DC)
Action Comics #976 (DC)
Peter Tomasi and Patrick Gleason are their usual sensational selves in the first issue, while Dan Jurgens continues to struggle to adapt to modern storytelling in the second. But I like the "Reborn" concept and how Mxyzptlk was revealed to be behind the Clark Kent mystery, and how Jurgens gets to unique disparate continuities in the conclusion, which feels right regardless of my other qualms.
X-O Manowar #1 (Valiant)
Matt Kindt again, in this quasi-reboot of the franchise, completely nailing it. Might be viewed as the Dark Knight Returns/"Old Man Logan" for comics' most famous Visigoth.
Thursday, June 4, 2015
The Amazing Spider-Man: Renew Your Vows #1 (Marvel)
writer: Dan Slott
artist: Adam Kubert
To call this disappointing would be an insult to disappointment. One of the many spin-off titles from Secret Warsthat in no way ape what DC just did with Convergence, Renew Your Vows seemed like Spider-Man I actually wanted to read again. Because it hearkened back to the era where I most wanted to read Spider-Man, the bi-weekly period where a team of writers wrote one excellent story after another, culminating in "O.M.I.T.," the sequel to "One More Day," the story that kicked it off. Otherwise known as the end of the Peter Parker/Mary Jane marriange. Which Renew Your Vows is supposed to correct.
Yeah, so that doesn't really happen. And I don't know, but does this pretty much mean the whole Dan Slott era that succeeded the bi-weeklies really wasn't for me? Because Slott's time with Spidey continued the arc-heavy period that he succeeded, but at the cost of distancing the wall-crawler from most of what he had once been. This was the period where Peter finally got the hi-tech job that made him stop having to mope around all the time because things never work out for him (even though the greatest success from this career turn seems owed to Doctor Octopus from the Doctor Spider-Man era that was...much more of a Doc Ock story than it was a Spider-Man story).
Slott's the writer of Renew Your Vows. He seems to have been absolutely the wrong choice.
This happy return to the marriage era is immediately presented as less than ideal, MJ depicted as a nagging wife. And so why are we even doing this? I have no idea. Then we find out Spider-Man is doing a lot of overtime because other superheroes aren't doing their part to catch bad guys. Then we find out why. Then we meetAmazo Regent. And for some reason, Venom is the villain who threatens everything Spider-Man holds dear. Again, I have no idea why. What does Venom have to do with Spider-Man's secret identity? Slott doesn't explain. It would make far more sense if, say, Norman Osborn or any villain remotely related to "One More Day" or anything from the "Big Time" (bi-weekly) era were involved...But no, Venom. For some reason.
Then Spidey resolves this by killing Venom. Then we fast-forward a bit and the bouncing baby Adam Kubert can't quite pull off early on is older, and we learn that Peter has consciously decided to let Regent rule New York...And on the cover for next issue? Apparently...Venom.
It's a nightmare! And I will not be bothering to check back in. I've seen people complaining about the overall quality of the Convergence spin-offs. I personally questioned the value of Convergence: Superman, which finally gave us a story with Lois and Clark having a baby. I mean, a little late, right? (Except that's a trio that might show up again if DC ever follows up on their role in helping sort out Crisis On Infinite Earths as suggested in Convergence #8.) Renew Your Vows ends up like a bad rephrasing of "Old Man Logan," a Wolverine arc that has also been revived for Secret Wars. (I nearly decided to buy that first issue from last week after all. I could still do so. We'll see.) I have fellow bloggers gushing over Secret Wars so far. But if the rest of its spin-offs are like this...
artist: Adam Kubert
To call this disappointing would be an insult to disappointment. One of the many spin-off titles from Secret Wars
Yeah, so that doesn't really happen. And I don't know, but does this pretty much mean the whole Dan Slott era that succeeded the bi-weeklies really wasn't for me? Because Slott's time with Spidey continued the arc-heavy period that he succeeded, but at the cost of distancing the wall-crawler from most of what he had once been. This was the period where Peter finally got the hi-tech job that made him stop having to mope around all the time because things never work out for him (even though the greatest success from this career turn seems owed to Doctor Octopus from the Doctor Spider-Man era that was...much more of a Doc Ock story than it was a Spider-Man story).
Slott's the writer of Renew Your Vows. He seems to have been absolutely the wrong choice.
This happy return to the marriage era is immediately presented as less than ideal, MJ depicted as a nagging wife. And so why are we even doing this? I have no idea. Then we find out Spider-Man is doing a lot of overtime because other superheroes aren't doing their part to catch bad guys. Then we find out why. Then we meet
Then Spidey resolves this by killing Venom. Then we fast-forward a bit and the bouncing baby Adam Kubert can't quite pull off early on is older, and we learn that Peter has consciously decided to let Regent rule New York...And on the cover for next issue? Apparently...Venom.
It's a nightmare! And I will not be bothering to check back in. I've seen people complaining about the overall quality of the Convergence spin-offs. I personally questioned the value of Convergence: Superman, which finally gave us a story with Lois and Clark having a baby. I mean, a little late, right? (Except that's a trio that might show up again if DC ever follows up on their role in helping sort out Crisis On Infinite Earths as suggested in Convergence #8.) Renew Your Vows ends up like a bad rephrasing of "Old Man Logan," a Wolverine arc that has also been revived for Secret Wars. (I nearly decided to buy that first issue from last week after all. I could still do so. We'll see.) I have fellow bloggers gushing over Secret Wars so far. But if the rest of its spin-offs are like this...
Wednesday, June 18, 2014
Superior Spider-Man #30 (Marvel)
writer: Dan Slott, Christos Gage
artist: Giuseppe Camuncoli
As everyone knew must happen when the Doctor Spider-Man era began, Peter Parker officially reclaims his identity/body from Otto Octavius, the erstwhile Doctor Octopus. This is the issue where that happens.
It's actually kind of disappointing. Maybe it's because I've read precious little of the Doctor Spider-Man arc (my coinage) but I would've thought Otto might get a bigger denouement. As it is, it's basically Peter figuring out that he can control his own body even with Otto's mind running the show, Otto deciding that only Peter can resolve the current crisis, and then voluntarily sitting himself down to the device that can undo what he did.
And what's most disappointing is that Otto's emotional goodbye, which in theory is very affecting, is completely undercut but severe brevity. Otto's happiest memories flit by. And basically, he's gone. Peter's back. Swaps costumes. That's it. The end. Issue done.
What somehow even more embarrassing is that half the issue is given over to Black Widow #1. Not because it's Black Widow or anything. It's a decent read and all, as far as I know drawing heavily from the character as depicted in Captain America: The Winter Soldier.
I just don't see why one of the pivotal moments, a truly historic Spider-Man occasion, after a long arc, plays like a glorified prelude to a character who has nothing to do with him, the arc, the series, anything. I understand that Marvel probably included this in other comics as well, but I don't see why it should have been done with this one. I mean, seriously? Really?
And so that's the underwhelmed reaction to an event that ends up played off more as a shrug than a milestone.
| via Inside Pulse. Imagine if this were his permanent headgear! |
It's actually kind of disappointing. Maybe it's because I've read precious little of the Doctor Spider-Man arc (my coinage) but I would've thought Otto might get a bigger denouement. As it is, it's basically Peter figuring out that he can control his own body even with Otto's mind running the show, Otto deciding that only Peter can resolve the current crisis, and then voluntarily sitting himself down to the device that can undo what he did.
And what's most disappointing is that Otto's emotional goodbye, which in theory is very affecting, is completely undercut but severe brevity. Otto's happiest memories flit by. And basically, he's gone. Peter's back. Swaps costumes. That's it. The end. Issue done.
What somehow even more embarrassing is that half the issue is given over to Black Widow #1. Not because it's Black Widow or anything. It's a decent read and all, as far as I know drawing heavily from the character as depicted in Captain America: The Winter Soldier.
I just don't see why one of the pivotal moments, a truly historic Spider-Man occasion, after a long arc, plays like a glorified prelude to a character who has nothing to do with him, the arc, the series, anything. I understand that Marvel probably included this in other comics as well, but I don't see why it should have been done with this one. I mean, seriously? Really?
And so that's the underwhelmed reaction to an event that ends up played off more as a shrug than a milestone.
Thursday, March 14, 2013
Quick Hits: Doctor Spider-Man (Marvel)
As everyone knows by now, one of the biggest comic book stories at the close of 2012 was Doctor Octopus switching minds with Peter Parker and thus becoming Spider-Man, and obnoxiously continually plugging the name of the new series that would replace the long-running Amazing Spider-Man.
All of this began in Amazing Spider-Man #698, in which the switch actually occurred. I finally picked up a copy at Barnes & Noble, because this story for better or worse is a big deal. It's Amazing Spider-Man #700, however, that everyone latched onto, an oversized celebration that forced Otto Octavius to relive Peter's greatest moments, the ones that helped shape his life, and therefore made Doc Ock realize what a complete joke his criminal career had been, thereby making the transition into Spider-Man not just about being his own worst enemy but a curious kind of redemption.
Avenging Spider-Man #15.1 will probably be overlooked by just about everyone forever, but it's a nice transitional meditation on the whole affair, and I'm glad it was available when I finally decided I cared and everything else wasn't.
Superior Spider-Man #1, meanwhile, is pretty much exactly what you'd expect. Otto isn't quite as benevolent as Peter's Wonderful Life might have led readers to believe, but most readers weren't really paying attention to the details, and neither was writer Dan Slott, who appears to be as conflicted by the whole story as his lead character. On the one hand he's had to acknowledge for impatient and bothered readers that this is all temporary, and on the other he's had to pretend that it is. In the meantime it's all a game of trying to exploit it to the best possible degree. Slott calls this the biggest and best story he's ever wanted to tell, and in a lot of ways it is. It was pretty awesome when Sylar and Nathan Petrelli did it in the fourth season of Heroes, too.
Doctor Spider-Man really exists because of the Brand New Day era, where everything old was made new again, which somehow left dear Otto on the verge of death for years, constantly attempting one last desperate ploy after another. Slott himself, once he launched his Big Time era, seemed to leave Otto out of his plans, and now here he is, in the middle of the biggest plan of them all. All pretty shocking for an iconic villain who starred in the most popular of the Spider-Man movies.
Everyone knows that Peter will get his body back. Will Otto have changed at all when he's evicted from his superior footing? Will he even survive? Only time will tell. Fascinating stuff told tolerably well in the meantime...
Wednesday, February 29, 2012
Quarter Bin #32 "Kaboom, Slott's Spider-Man, LXG, and Bane"
KABOOM #s 1-3 (Awesome)
From July, August, & December 1999:
I eagerly read the original KABOOM mini-series from creators Jeph Loeb and Jeff Matsuda, but the follow-up came after I quit reading comics in 1999, so I never even knew it existed until strolling through the back issues at Heroes & Dragons and coming across some covers I didn’t recognize. The good news is that Awesome did manage to produce some more KABOOM before it imploded, the not-so-good news is that some if not all the charm from the original comics were lost in translation, the loss of Matsuda and addition of Keron Grant on art. Grant apparently had no idea that the art was what helped make KABOOM shine in its previous incarnation, with Matsuda driving the narrative Loeb crafted into something that resembled the comics DC was doing at the time with the same youth leads, but with an expansive concept that introduced something new to the genre, something I hoped would have staying power. With more generic art, it’s not as easy for the story (shaped by Rob Liefeld but still scripted by Loeb, who doesn’t get near enough respect from fans) to distinguish itself from the sea of indy comics competing for attention, which is probably what happened to the comics scene at the time in general, not just Awesome (which boasted its biggest gun with Alan Moore, who quickly bolted to create America’s Best Comics when this gig ended). Needless to say, whether or not this version of KABOOM impacted me the same way as the first one, I remain a fan, hoping that more will come of it.
THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #655 (Marvel)
From April 2011:
This will not be the only pretty-recent back issue in the coming weeks (there’s one more), but it’s an example of what started to happen last year, when I really was trying to quit spending money I don’t really have on things I enjoy, namely new comics, and not always completely succeeding, mostly because I find comics to be a continually rewarding medium. Dan Slott’s Big Time was shaping up to be a worthy successor to Brand New Day, perhaps even better, but I couldn’t justify trying to read a mostly weekly series when I shouldn’t have been reading any series at all. Early in the run I heard about this issue, marked by a stark white cover by Marcos Martin, in which Peter Parker mourns the death of J. Jonah Jameson’s wife, a personal defeat at a time when it seemed like Slott would finally help develop Spider-Man into less of a caricature than he tends to be portrayed by most creators (as I’ve suggested, Brand New Day was a giant exception, which is why I enjoyed following it, the only time I’ve been a regular reader of one of my favorite superheroes) than a multi-dimensional character with a fully-developed world worthy of his famous origins and not just the typical Marvel machine built around hype and generic storytelling. Yet it appears that even Slott has succumbed to the pressure of delivering Spider-Man as he’s been traditionally presented by the House of Ideas, making this perhaps the standout issue to date of his run, and now perhaps atypical. So I suggest you read it, and prove me wrong if I’m wrong, because I don’t have the experience to be comprehensive of Slott’s run for the past year, falling back on the impression I’ve gotten from events like “Spider-Island,” which don’t feel like they’re worthy of the intimate approach I originally assumed Slott was going to stick with.
THE LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARY GENTLEMEN #5 (America’s Best Comics)
From June 2000:
Hey! So let me now chime in here at Comics Reader on one of the biggest comic book stories of 2012, namely DC’s decision to go forward with BEFORE WATCHMEN, and Alan Moore’s bitter renunciation of the project. There’s are reasons to side with Moore, and there are reasons to believe that he’s a bitter old man intent to reject anyone trying to make him, or his legacy, do anything without his explicit approval. Moore is without a doubt one of the greatest writers to ever grace the medium, but at this point he’s better known for being crotchety about film adaptations and angrily swearing off any notion of the mainstream, instead retreating to, well, others people’s creations and his interpretations of them. Some people defend his decision to do this by saying it’s different from what he himself has been disputing all these years, because he’s alive and, say, Mark Twain is not. He can make decisions based on whether or not he personally created something and can make a public and legal claim to that effect, whereas Twain cannot (because, to borrow from Monty Python, he has ceased to be). I respect Moore, but he’s become a writer less influenced by the need to create new and compelling work than provoking a reaction. LXG is a prime example, blending a number of disparate literary creations to assemble a historic Justice League. There’s nothing particularly wrong with that, and this issue (the penultimate one of the original mini-series) exhibits a sober result, but I can’t help lament the loss of the guy who used to do this stuff to more productive results. Is there an argument out there that LXG is comparable to WATCHMEN? Because I think that would make a far more compelling argument than anything Moore has said in the past few months.
CHECKMATE #12 (DC)
From May 2007:
Speaking of diminished returns, even Greg Rucka apparently didn’t have anything relevant to say about Bane a few years ago. (I suppose the case would be different if Bane had boobs, because Fire receives more nuanced treatment in this issue.) It’s incredible to me that a character who started out with such a specific and dramatic origin as Bane was so easily reduced to “that big dude who used drugs to pump up and break Batman’s back,” and set off on increasingly meaningless further adventures, eventually winding up a virtual punchline and not even a shadow of his former self in Gail Simone’s SECRET SIX, a book shared by Catman, whose revival in the same INFINITE CRISIS prelude material that helped bring us this incarnation of Checkmate rescued him from exactly that fate (or, to be more accurate, actually made a character out of him). Thank god for Christopher Nolan, is all. Thank god he was able to figure out that there was a reason Bane was created in the first place, and it wasn’t to slum by on a distortion or outright simplification of his reason for existence. I think there’s BANE OF THE DEMON waiting for me to read somewhere, perhaps the only other time besides “Knightfall” and the two VENGEANCE OF BANE one-shots where reading Bane is actually worthwhile. I may have to work on tracking that one down, and quit expecting to read just any random appearance to not be, more or less, a waste of my time…
(This week's column brought to you by Bitter Returns.)
From July, August, & December 1999:
I eagerly read the original KABOOM mini-series from creators Jeph Loeb and Jeff Matsuda, but the follow-up came after I quit reading comics in 1999, so I never even knew it existed until strolling through the back issues at Heroes & Dragons and coming across some covers I didn’t recognize. The good news is that Awesome did manage to produce some more KABOOM before it imploded, the not-so-good news is that some if not all the charm from the original comics were lost in translation, the loss of Matsuda and addition of Keron Grant on art. Grant apparently had no idea that the art was what helped make KABOOM shine in its previous incarnation, with Matsuda driving the narrative Loeb crafted into something that resembled the comics DC was doing at the time with the same youth leads, but with an expansive concept that introduced something new to the genre, something I hoped would have staying power. With more generic art, it’s not as easy for the story (shaped by Rob Liefeld but still scripted by Loeb, who doesn’t get near enough respect from fans) to distinguish itself from the sea of indy comics competing for attention, which is probably what happened to the comics scene at the time in general, not just Awesome (which boasted its biggest gun with Alan Moore, who quickly bolted to create America’s Best Comics when this gig ended). Needless to say, whether or not this version of KABOOM impacted me the same way as the first one, I remain a fan, hoping that more will come of it.
THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #655 (Marvel)
From April 2011:
This will not be the only pretty-recent back issue in the coming weeks (there’s one more), but it’s an example of what started to happen last year, when I really was trying to quit spending money I don’t really have on things I enjoy, namely new comics, and not always completely succeeding, mostly because I find comics to be a continually rewarding medium. Dan Slott’s Big Time was shaping up to be a worthy successor to Brand New Day, perhaps even better, but I couldn’t justify trying to read a mostly weekly series when I shouldn’t have been reading any series at all. Early in the run I heard about this issue, marked by a stark white cover by Marcos Martin, in which Peter Parker mourns the death of J. Jonah Jameson’s wife, a personal defeat at a time when it seemed like Slott would finally help develop Spider-Man into less of a caricature than he tends to be portrayed by most creators (as I’ve suggested, Brand New Day was a giant exception, which is why I enjoyed following it, the only time I’ve been a regular reader of one of my favorite superheroes) than a multi-dimensional character with a fully-developed world worthy of his famous origins and not just the typical Marvel machine built around hype and generic storytelling. Yet it appears that even Slott has succumbed to the pressure of delivering Spider-Man as he’s been traditionally presented by the House of Ideas, making this perhaps the standout issue to date of his run, and now perhaps atypical. So I suggest you read it, and prove me wrong if I’m wrong, because I don’t have the experience to be comprehensive of Slott’s run for the past year, falling back on the impression I’ve gotten from events like “Spider-Island,” which don’t feel like they’re worthy of the intimate approach I originally assumed Slott was going to stick with.
THE LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARY GENTLEMEN #5 (America’s Best Comics)
From June 2000:
Hey! So let me now chime in here at Comics Reader on one of the biggest comic book stories of 2012, namely DC’s decision to go forward with BEFORE WATCHMEN, and Alan Moore’s bitter renunciation of the project. There’s are reasons to side with Moore, and there are reasons to believe that he’s a bitter old man intent to reject anyone trying to make him, or his legacy, do anything without his explicit approval. Moore is without a doubt one of the greatest writers to ever grace the medium, but at this point he’s better known for being crotchety about film adaptations and angrily swearing off any notion of the mainstream, instead retreating to, well, others people’s creations and his interpretations of them. Some people defend his decision to do this by saying it’s different from what he himself has been disputing all these years, because he’s alive and, say, Mark Twain is not. He can make decisions based on whether or not he personally created something and can make a public and legal claim to that effect, whereas Twain cannot (because, to borrow from Monty Python, he has ceased to be). I respect Moore, but he’s become a writer less influenced by the need to create new and compelling work than provoking a reaction. LXG is a prime example, blending a number of disparate literary creations to assemble a historic Justice League. There’s nothing particularly wrong with that, and this issue (the penultimate one of the original mini-series) exhibits a sober result, but I can’t help lament the loss of the guy who used to do this stuff to more productive results. Is there an argument out there that LXG is comparable to WATCHMEN? Because I think that would make a far more compelling argument than anything Moore has said in the past few months.
CHECKMATE #12 (DC)
From May 2007:
Speaking of diminished returns, even Greg Rucka apparently didn’t have anything relevant to say about Bane a few years ago. (I suppose the case would be different if Bane had boobs, because Fire receives more nuanced treatment in this issue.) It’s incredible to me that a character who started out with such a specific and dramatic origin as Bane was so easily reduced to “that big dude who used drugs to pump up and break Batman’s back,” and set off on increasingly meaningless further adventures, eventually winding up a virtual punchline and not even a shadow of his former self in Gail Simone’s SECRET SIX, a book shared by Catman, whose revival in the same INFINITE CRISIS prelude material that helped bring us this incarnation of Checkmate rescued him from exactly that fate (or, to be more accurate, actually made a character out of him). Thank god for Christopher Nolan, is all. Thank god he was able to figure out that there was a reason Bane was created in the first place, and it wasn’t to slum by on a distortion or outright simplification of his reason for existence. I think there’s BANE OF THE DEMON waiting for me to read somewhere, perhaps the only other time besides “Knightfall” and the two VENGEANCE OF BANE one-shots where reading Bane is actually worthwhile. I may have to work on tracking that one down, and quit expecting to read just any random appearance to not be, more or less, a waste of my time…
(This week's column brought to you by Bitter Returns.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


